Chinese Herbal Medicines (CHM)  2014, Vol. 6 Issue (4): 328-331
0
  PDF    
Chemical Constituents from Leaves of Oplopanax horridus
Kai-yue Cao1, Chun-feng Qiao1, Xian-qiang Chen1, Chong-zhi Wang2, Chun-su Yuan2, Jing Zhao1 , Shao-ping Li1    
1. State Key Laboratory of Quality Research in Chinese Medicine, Institute of Chinese Medical Sciences, University of Macau, Macao SAR, China
2. Tang Center for Herbal Medicine Research, Pritzker School of Medicine, University of Chicago, Chicago IL 60637, USA
Corresponding author: Zhao J Tel: +86-853- 2884 1358 Fax: +86-853-2884 1358 E-mail: zhaojing.cpu@163.com † These authors contribute equally to this work.
Fund: NIH/NCCAM (AT004418 and AT005362 to C. S. Yuan); University of Macau (UL015/09-Y1 to S. P. Li) grants
Received: May 1, 2014; Revised: June 10, 2014; Accepted: June 25, 2014; Available online: November 20, 2014
Abstract: Objective To study the chemical constituents from the leaves of Oplopanax horridus. Methods The chemical constituents were isolated and purified by column chromatography on silica gel and Sephadex LH-20 gel columns,1H-NMR and 13C-NMR were applied for the identification of chemical structure. Results Ten compounds were isolated and identified as dammara-20,24-dien-3β-ol acetate (1),phytol (2),16Z,19Z- pentacosadienoic acid (3),β-sitosterol (4),(3S,8S)-falcarindiol (5),maltol (6),acankoreagenin (7),daucosterol (8),stigmasterol-3-O-β-D-glucopyranoside (9),and acankoreoside A (10). Conclusion Compounds 1-3,6,and 10 are isolated from this plant for the first time. Compounds 1-3 and 6 are isolated from the plants in genus Oplopanax Miq. for the first time. Moreover,Compounds 1,3,and 6 are isolated from the plants in the family of Araliaceae for the first time.
Key words: Araliaceae     chemotaxonomy     Oplopanax horridus     triterpenoid    
1. Introduction

Plants of the genus Oplopanax Miq.(Araliaceae)are mainly distributed in eastern Asia and northwestern America. This genus consists of three species, such as Oplopanax elatus Nakai, O. japonicus(Nakai)Nakai, O. horridus(Smith)Miq.(Calway et al, 2012). O. horridus, or Devil’s club, is a commonly used traditional folk herb by indigenous people native to the Pacific Northwest of North America. Until now, O. horridus has been used for the treatment of respiratory diseases, cardiovascular diseases, gastrointestinal diseases, diabetes, arthritis, and cancer(Calway et al, 2012). Previous phytochemical investigations on O. horridus mainly focus on the root bark, which have revealed the presence of polyynes, triterpene glycosides, phenolic glycosides, sesquiterpenes, lignans, and polyenes (Calway et al, 2012). Actually, leaf of O. horridus is a traditionally used medicinal part to treat arthritis and rheumatism(Trevor et al, 2004). Moreover, bioactive study showed triterpenoids from the leaves of O. horridus has significant inhibitory effects on human hepatoma carcinoma cells(HepG-2), human colon cancer cells(HCT116), human lung carcinoma cells(NCI-H460), and human gastric cancer cells(MGC803)(Liu et al, 2012). However, the phytochemical investigation on the leaves of this plant is rarely reported. To further investigate the chemical constituents from the leaves, we isolated and identified 10 compounds in this study and discussed their chemotaxonomic significance.

2. Materials and methods 2.1 Apparatus and reagents

The 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker AV-500 Spectrometer(Germany)with tetramethylsilane(TMS)as an internal st and ard. Silica gel(100-200 and 200-300 mesh)(Qingdao Marine Chemical Co., Ltd., China) and Alltech RP-C18 silica gel(40-63 μm, USA)were used for column chromatography(CC). Precoated silica gel GF254 plates(Qingdao Marine Co., Ltd., China)were used for TLC.

2.2 Plant material

Leaves of Oplopanax horridus(Smith)Miq. were obtained from Alaska, USA, in September 2012, and were identified by Dr. Chun-su Yuan. A voucher specimen was deposited at the State Key Laboratory of Quality Research in Chinese Medicine, Institute of Chinese Medical Sciences, University of Macau, Macao SAR, China.

2.3 Extraction and isolation

Air-dried and powdered leaves of O. horridus(2.2 kg)were extracted with 70% ethanol at room temperature for three times. After the removal of ethanol by concentration, the extract(550 g)was suspended in water and partitioned sequentially with petroleum ether, EtOAc, and n-BuOH, respectively.

The petroleum ether extract(39.51 g)was separated into 16 fractions(Frs. 1-16)by using silica gel column(petroleum ether-EtOAC, 20:1→1:1). Frs. 1 and 2 were purified by repeated silica gel and Sephadex LH-20(MeOH-CHCl3)to give compounds 1(126 mg), 2(200 mg), and 3(900 mg).

The EtOAc extract(39.78 g)was separated into 17 fractions(Frs. 1-17)by using silica gel column(petroleum ether-EtOAC, 20:1→1:1). Frs. 3-5 were purified by Sephadex LH-20 column(MeOH)to give compound 4(205 mg), the same method was applied to obtain compounds 5(65 mg) and 6(33 mg)from Frs. 6 and 7. Frs. 13-16 were subjected to MCI gel column(MeOH), followed by MPLC over on silica gel(CHCl3-acetone 20:1→1:1) and Sephadex LH-20 column(MeOH)to give compound 7(260 mg).

The n-BuOH extract(162.68 g)was separated over silica gel(CHCl3-MeOH 100:1→0:1)to afford 15 fractions(Frs. 1-15). Compounds 8 and 9(mixed, 30 mg)were obtained from Fr. 9 as precipitate in MeOH. Frs. 14 and 15 were subjected to MPLC over on silica gel(CHCl3-MeOH 100:1→0:1), ODS gel(MeOH-H2O 1:8→1:0) and Sephadex LH-20(MeOH)column to give compound10(1.4 g). The chemical structures of compounds 1-10 are shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1 Chemical structures of compounds 1-10
3. Results and discussion 3.1 Structure identification

Compound 1: white crystal. 1H-NMR(400 Hz, CDCl3)δ: 5.13(1H, t, J = 6.9 Hz, H-24), 4.74(1H, s, H-21a), 4.71(1H, s, H-21b), 4.48(1H, m, H-3α), 2.04(3H, s), 1.69(3H, s), 1.61(3H, s), 0.97(3H, s), 0.87(3H, s), 0.86(3H, s), 0.85(6H, s). 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CDCl3)δ: 38.8(C-1), 23.7(C-2), 80.9(C-3), 37.9(C-4), 56.0(C-5), 18.2(C-6), 35.4(C-7), 40.5(C-8), 50.9(C-9), 37.2(C-10), 21.4(C-11), 24.9(C-12), 47.8(C-13), 49.4(C-14), 31.4(C-15), 27.1(C-16), 45.3(C-17), 15.9(C-18), 16.3(C-19), 152.7(C-20), 107.5(C-21), 34.2(C-22), 28.9(C-23), 124.5(C-24), 131.4(C-25), 25.7(C-26), 17.7(C-27), 28.0(C-28), 15.6(C-29), 16.5(C-30), 170.9(C-1′), 21.3(C-2′). The 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR data were in agreement with those given in literature(Zhang and Chen, 2011), and compound 1 was identified as dammara-20, 24- dien-3β-ol acetate.

Compound 2: colorless oil. 1H-NMR(400 Hz, CDCl3)δ: 5.41(1H, dt, J = 6.9 Hz, 1.2 Hz, H-2), 4.15(2H, d, J = 6.9 Hz, H-1), 1.98(2H, m, H-4), 1.66(3H, s, H-20), 1.52(1H, m, H-15), 0.83-0.87(12H, m, H-16, H-17, H-18, H-19). 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CDCl3)δ: 59.4(C-1), 123.1(C-2), 140.2(C-3), 39.8(C-4), 39.3(C-5), 37.4(C-6), 32.8(C-7), 37.3(C-8), 37.3(C-9), 36.6(C-10), 32.7(C-11), 24.4(C-12), 24.8(C-13), 25.1(C-14), 27.9(C-15), 19.7(C-16), 22.6(C-17), 22.6(C-18), 19.7(C-19), 16.1(C-20). The 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR data were in agreement with those given in literature(Feng et al, 2008), and compound 2 was identified as phytol.

Compound3: colorless crystal. 1H-NMR(400 Hz, CDCl3)δ: 5.35(4H, m, H-16, H-17, H-19, H-20), 2.77(2H, m, H-18), 2.34(2H, t, J = 7.5 Hz, H-2), 2.04(4H, m, H-15, H-21), 1.63(2H, quint, J = 7.2 Hz, H-3), 1.20-1.30(28H, m, H-4-H-14, H-22-H-24), 0.87(3H, t, J = 6.4, H-25). 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CDCl3)δ: 180.0(C-1), 34.0(C-2), 24.7(C-3), 29.0-29.6(C-4-C-14), 27.1(C-15), 130.0(C-16), 128.0(C-17), 25.6(C-18), 130.2(C-19), 127.8(C-20), 27.1(C-21), 29.7(C-22), 31.9(C-23), 22.6(C-24), 14.0(C-25). The 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR data were in agreement with those given in literature(Huang et al, 2007), and compound 3 was identified as 16Z, 19Z-pentacosadienoic acid.

Compound 4: colorless needle crystal. Its Rf value is in accordance with that of reference substance(β-sitosterol), and compound 4 was identified as β-sitosterol.

Compound5: colorless oil. 1H-NMR(400 Hz, CDCl3)δ: 5.94(1H, ddd, J = 15.6, 10.2, 5.4 Hz, H-2), 5.60(1H, dt, J = 10.6, 7.4 Hz, H-10), 5.51(1H, d, J = 8.2 Hz, H-9), 5.47(1H, d, J = 16.8 Hz, H-1a), 5.25(1H, d, J = 10.2 Hz, H-1b), 5.20(1H, d, J = 8.2 Hz, H-8), 4.94(1H, d, J = 5.3 Hz, H-3), 2.11(2H, m, H-11), 1.38(2H, m, H-12), 1.27(8H, m, H-13, H-14, H-15, H-16), 0.88(3H, t, J = 7.0 Hz, H-17). The 1H-NMR data was in agreement with that given in literature(Tamura et al, 2010), and compound 5 was identified as(3S, 8S)-falcarindiol.

Compound6:white needle crystal.1H-NMR(400 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 7.92(1H, d, J = 5.5 Hz, H-6), 6.37(1H, d, J = 5.5 Hz, H-5), 2.33(3H, s, 2-CH3). 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 152.1(C-2), 144.5(C-3), 175.2(C-4), 114.4(C-5), 156.2(C-6), 14.2(2-CH3). The 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR data were in agreement with those given in literature(Sun et al, 1995), and compound 6 was identified as maltol.

Compound7: white needle crystal. 1H-NMR(400 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 4.71(1H, d, J = 1.4 Hz, H-29b), 4.59(1H, s, H-29a), 3.72(1H, s, H-3), 3.05(1H, m, H-19), 1.70(3H, s, H-30), 1.15(3H, s, H-24), 1.07(3H, s, H-26), 0.98(3H, s, H-25), 0.91(3H, s, H-27). 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 33.4(C-1), 26.1(C-2), 73.8(C-3), 52.4(C-4), 45.4(C-5), 21.8(C-6), 35.1(C-7), 42.4(C-8), 51.8(C-9), 38.0(C-10), 22.3(C-11), 26.8(C-12), 39.6(C-13), 43.8(C-14), 30.8(C-15), 33.3(C-16), 57.5(C-17), 50.4(C-18), 48.5(C-19), 151.9(C-20), 31.7(C-21), 38.1(C-22), 180.3(C-23), 17.7(C-24), 16.9(C-25), 16.8(C-26), 15.1(C-27), 180.0(C-28), 110.1(C-29), 19.5(C-30). The 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR data were in agreement with those given in literature(An et al, 2009), and compound 7 was identified as acankoreagenin.

Compound8: white solid. 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 37.4(C-1), 29.4(C-2), 78.5(C-3), 39.9(C-4), 140.8(C-5), 121.8(C-6), 30.2(C-7), 29.8(C-8), 50.3(C-9), 36.3(C-10), 19.9(C-11), 39.3(C-12), 42.4(C-13), 56.2(C-14), 24.4(C-15), 28.4(C-16), 56.0(C-17), 12.0(C-18), 19.1(C-19), 36.8(C-20), 18.9(C-21), 34.1(C-22), 25.6(C-23), 46.0(C-24), 29.2(C-25), 18.9(C-26), 19.3(C-27), 23.3(C-28), 12.4(C-29), 102.5(C-1′), 75.2(C-2′), 78.0(C-3′), 71.6(C-4′), 78.5(C-5′), 62.8(C-6′). The 13C-NMR data was in agreement with that given in literature(Yoo et al, 2006), and compound 8 was identified as daucosterol.

Compound9: white solid. 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 37.4(C-1), 29.4(C-2), 78.5(C-3), 40.6(C-4), 140.8(C-5), 122.8(C-6), 32.1(C-7), 32.0(C-8), 51.3(C-9), 36.3(C-10), 21.4(C-11), 42.3(C-12), 42.4(C-13), 56.8(C-14), 24.4(C-15), 26.4(C-16), 56.7(C-17), 12.0(C-18), 19.1(C-19), 36.8(C-20), 18.9(C-21), 138.7(C-22), 129.4(C-23), 46.0(C-24), 29.2(C-25), 21.2(C-26), 19.3(C-27), 23.3(C-28), 11.9(C-29), 102.5(C-1′), 75.2(C-2′), 78.3(C-3′), 71.6(C-4′), 78.5(C-5′), 62.8(C-6′). The 13C-NMR data was in agreement with that given in literature(Liu et al, 2005), and compound 9 was identified as stigmasterol-3-O-β-D-glucopyranoside.

Compound10: white solid. 1H-NMR(400 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 5.45(1H, d, J = 8.0 Hz, H-1 of Glc), 4.73(1H, s, H-1 of Rha), 4.60(1H, s, H-29b), 4.36(1H, d, J = 8.0 Hz, H-1 of Glc′), 4.10(1H, m, H-29a), 1.69(3H, s, H-30), 1.24(3H, d, J = 6.4 Hz, CH3 of Rha), 1.13(3H, s, H-24), 1.04(3H, s, H-26), 0.96(3H, s, H-25), 0.89(3H, s, H-27). 13C-NMR(100 Hz, CD3OD)δ: 33.5(C-1), 26.8(C-2), 73.7(C-3), 52.3(C-4), 45.6(C-5), 22.2(C-6), 35.1(C-7), 42.5(C-8), 51.8(C-9), 38.0(C-10), 21.8(C-11), 26.1(C-12), 39.3(C-13), 43.7(C-14), 30.8(C-15), 32.8(C-16), 57.9(C-17), 50.5(C-18), 48.3(C-19), 151.7(C-20), 31.5(C-21), 37.6(C-22), 181.0(C-23), 17.8(C-24), 17.0(C-25), 16.9(C-26), 15.1(C-27), 176.3(C-28), 110.4(C-29), 19.5(C-30), 95.2(C-1 glc), 73.9(C-2 glc), 79.6(C-3 glc), 71.0(C-4 glc), 78.0(C-5 glc), 69.5(C-6 glc), 104.5( C-1 glc'), 75.2(C-2 glc'), 76.7(C-3 glc'), 78.2(C-4 glc'), 76.8(C-5 glc'), 61.9(C-6 glc'), 102.9(C-1 rha), 72.2(C-2 rha), 72.4(C-3 rha), 73.7(C-4 rha), 70.6(C-5 rha), 17.8(C-6 rha). The 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR data were in agreement with those given in literature(Van Kiem et al, 2003), and compound 10 was identified as acankoreoside A.

3.2 Chemotaxonomic significance

Ten compounds were isolated and identified from the leaves of O. horridus, including three triterpenoids(1, 7, 10), one diterpenoid(2), one polyyne(5), one pyrone(6), one unsaturated fatty acid(3) and three steroids(4, 8, 9). Compounds 1-3, 6, and 10 were reported from this species for the first time. Compounds 1-3 and 6 are isolated from the genus Oplopanax Miq. for the first time. Moreover, Compounds 1, 3, and 6 are isolated from the family of Araliaceae for the first time.

Araliaceae, a big family of medicinal plants, comprises about 700 species in 55 genera, and is rich in triterpenoids which are the most representative components from this family(Hansen and Boll, 1986). In this study, two triterpenoids with high content(compounds 7 and 10)were isolated from O. horridus previously reported from the genera Schefflera J. R. et G. Forst.(Sung et al, 1991; Wanas et al, 2010), Brassaiopsis Decne. et Planch.(Van Kiem et al, 2003)Acanthopanax Miq.(Chang et al, 1998; Liu et al, 2002), and Oplopanax Miq.(Hirai et al, 1995; Liu et al, 2010; 2012). The similarity of triterpenoids suggests a potential close relationship among these genera.

Dammara-20, 24-dien-3β-ol acetate(1)has been mainly reported from the family Asteraceae, including Taraxacum Weber.(Saeki et al, 2013), Santolina Tourn.(Ferrari et al, 2005), Microglossa DC.(Schmidt et al, 2003), etc. In addition, some plants of Cruciferae, Boraginaceae, and Theaceae contain this compound as well. Although dammarane triterpenoid is very common in the family Araliaceae, especially in the genus Panax Linn., this component is the first report from the family Araliaceae. 16Z, 19Z- Pentacosadienoic acid(3)has been reported from Tagetes erecta L.(Asteraceae)(Huang et al, 2007) and freshwater Israeli sponges(Rezanka and Dembitsky, 2002). To our best knowledge, this is the second report about this component from natural herbs and first report from Araliaceae. Maltol(6)has been reported from many medicinal plants. Theoretically, it is considered as a product of Maillard reaction(Yaylayan and Mandeville, 1994). An example is that maltol exists in the red ginseng(steamed P. ginseng)but could not be detected in the fresh P. ginseng(Li et al, 1999). It indicates that maltol is a significant compound in red ginseng. In this study, as a natural product, this is the first report from Araliaceae. However, limited data on these three components are within other species of Araliaceae, and these data suggest further work on different species of Araliaceae is justified.

Phytol(2)exists commonly in many medicinal plants in different families. In Araliaceae, this compound has previously been isolated from Schefflera J. R. et G. Forst.(Kuo et al, 2002), Panax Linn.(Lai et al, 2010), Acanthopanax Miq.(Zhang and Liu, 2001), etc. This is the first report from the genus Oplopanax Miq.

参考文献
[1] An SY,Qian SH,Jiang JQ,Wang KC,2009. Chemical constituents in leaves of Acanthopanax gracilistylus. Chin Tradit Herb Drugs 40: 1528-1534.
[2] Calway T,Du GJ,Wang CZ,Huang WH,Zhao J,Li SP,Yuan CS,2012. Chemical and pharmacological studies of Oplopanax horridus,a North American botanical. J Nat Prod 66: 249-265.
[3] Chang SY,Yook CS,Nohara T,1998. Two new lupane-triterpene glycosides from leaves of Acanthopanax koreanum. Chem Pharm Bull 46: 163-165.
[4] Feng C,Li XM,Tian MQ,Wang BG,2008. Chemical constituents of medicinal mangrove plant Hibiscus tilisceus. Mar Sci 32: 57-60.
[5] Ferrari B,Tomi F,Casanova J,2005. Terpenes and acetylene derivatives from the roots of Santolina corsica (Asteraceae). Biochem Syst Ecol 33: 445-449.
[6] Hansen L,Boll PM,1986. Polyacetylenes in Araliaceae-Their chemistry,biosynthesis and biological significance. Phytochemistry 25: 285-293.
[7] Hirai Y,Murayama T,Miyakoshi M,Hirono S,Isoda S,Ideura N,Ida Y,Shoji J,Wang GS,Xu JD,1995. Three new lupane type glycosyl esters from Oplopanax japonicus leaves. J Nat Med-Tokyo 49: 462-467.
[8] Huang S,Zhou XL,Wang HY,Zhang GW,2007. Chemical constituents from the flowers of Tagetes erecta L. West Chin J Pharma Sci22: 370-373.
[9] Kuo YH,Lo JM,Chan YF,2002. Cytotoxic components from the leaves of Schefflera taiwaniana. J Chin Chem Soc-Taip 49: 427-431.
[10] Lai PH,Tian GH,Ji XH,Zhao H,2010. Study on volatile components and antimicrobial activities of the essential oil from the leaf of Panax japonicus var. major in Daba Mountain. Chin J Exp Tradit Med Form 16: 7-11.
[11] Li XG,Zheng YN,Liu MX,Zhang LL,1999. A study on maillard reaction and its products during processing of red ginseng. Chin J Chin Mat Med 24: 274-278.
[12] Liu GY,Zheng J,Yu ZX,Zhang J,Lin RC,2005. Study on sterols and triterpenes from the stems of Akebia quinata. Chin Med Mat 28: 1060-1062.
[13] Liu PP,Li M,Kang TG,Dou DQ,Smith DC,2010. New lupane-type triterpenoid saponins from leaves of Oplopanax horridus (Devil’s Club). Nat Prod Commun 5: 1019-1022.
[14] Liu PP,Qu Y,Dou DQ,Kang TG,Smith D,2012. Determination of anti-cancer constituents in Oplopanax horridus and Oplopanax elatus. J Chem Soc Pakistan 34: 419-423.
[15] Liu XQ,Chang SY,Park SY,Nohara T,Yook CS,2002. A new lupane-triterpene glycoside from the leaves of Acanthopanax gracilistylus. Arch Pharm Res 25: 831-836.
[16] Rezanka T,Dembitsky VM,2002. Multibranched polyunsaturated and very-long-chain fatty acids of freshwater Israeli sponges. J Natural Products 65: 709-713.
[17] Saeki D,Yamada T,In Y,Kajimoto T,Tanaka R,Iizuka Y,Nakane T, Takano A,Masuda K,2013. Officinatrione: An unusual (17S)-17,18- seco-lupane skeleton,and four novel lupane-type triterpenoids from the roots of Taraxacum officinale. Tetrahedron 69: 1583-1589.
[18] Schmidt TJ,Hildebrand MR,Willuhn G,2003. New dihydro- benzofurans and triterpenoids from roots of Microglossa pyrifolia. Planta Med 69: 258-264.
[19] Sun PY,Ye W,Zhao JF,Pei YP,Wang ZX,Chen YJ,Ogihara Y,Takeda T,1995. Studies on the constituents of Epimedium koreanum. Chem Pharm Bull 43: 703-704.
[20] Sung TV,Steglich W,Adam G,1991. Triterpene glycosides from Schefflera octophylla. Phytochemistry 30: 2349-2356.
[21] Tamura S,Ohno T,Hattori Y,Murakami N,2010. Establishment of absolute stereostructure of falcarindiol,algicidal principle against Heterocapsa circularisquama from Notopterygii Rhizoma. Tetrahedron Lett 51: 1523-1525.
[22] Trevor CL,Kristina S,Nancy JT,2004. Devil’s Club (Oplopanax horridus): An ethnobotanical review. Herbal Gram 62: 33-48.
[23] Van Kiem P,Dat NT,Van Minh C,Lee JJ,Kim YH,2003. Lupane-triterpenes from the leaves of Brassaiopsis glomerulata. Arch Pharm Res 26: 594-596.
[24] Wanas AS,Matsunami K,Orsuka H,Desoukey SY,Fouad MA,Kamel MS,2010. Triterpene glycosides and glucosyl esters,and a triterpene from the leaves of Schefflera actinophylla. Chem Pharm Bul 58: 1596-1601.
[25] Yaylayan VA,Mandeville S,1994. Stereochemical control of maltol formation in Maillard reaction. J Agr Food Chem 42: 771-775.
[26] Yoo JS,Ahn EM,Bang MH,Song MC,Yang HJ,Kim DH,Lee DY,Chung HG,Jeong TS,Lee KT,Choi MS,Baek NI,2006. Steroids from the aerial parts of Artemisia princeps Pampanini. Korean J Med Crop Sci 14: 273-277.
[27] Zhang LX,Liu H,2001. Comparative analysis of essential oils from stem-skins,leaves and fruitages of Acanthopanax Giraidii Harma with GC-MS technique. Chin J Basic Med TCM 7: 344-347.
[28] Zhang T,Chen RY,2011. Study on chemical constituents in roots of Inula racemosa. Chin Pharm J 46: 1159-1162.